Pioneer Woman Gumdrop Recipe

Pioneer Woman Gumdrop Recipe
5/5 - (17 votes)

If you have enough skills to make jello at home, you can make homemade gumdrop. Yes, it’s not hard once you learn the techniques. There are plenty of recipes online, and every recipe has its own ingredients. However, Pioneer woman gumdrops are the most popular ones so far. 

Pioneer Woman Gumdrop Recipe

The simplicity and adaptability of the gumdrops make this candy a delicious treat. Now, the gumdrops are delicate, and you can still carry them inside your purse or a bag. So, how do you make it at home? Follow our Pioneer Woman Gumdrop Recipe to learn how to make these gumdrops home. 

How to Make Gumdrops with Jello?

Making homemade gumdrops is pretty easy when you can make Jello. However, the recipe can yield a lot of variations in flavors. Although, it’s straightforward to make at home. There are two ways to make these beautiful gumdrops at home. 

You can pour them in a candy mold or just pour them in a small pan. After the candy is ready, you can cut them into small pieces. However, there’s another easy way to make these soft candies. Just use a small mold to get accurate shapes. 

Just as we said, you can use different food colors to make different versions of this candy. The option for switching up the flavors makes this gumdrop recipe a crowd favorite. You can complete the preparations a day earlier. After making the candies, refrigerate the candies overnight. The problem is that gumdrops tend to get harder once you start to store them. So, keeping them for a long time will make the gumdrops lose moisture. 

Anyway, we need five 15-count gumdrop molds for the ree Drummond gumdrops. And once all things are ready, we can start cooking. We need ingredients for the Gelatin mix and the sugar syrup. Finally, you will need ingredients for flavoring our gumdrops. 

Ingredients We Need

For the Gelatin Mix, we need:

Cold Water: We need ½ cup worth of cold water for the gelatin. Coldwater can easily mix our gelatin. 

Unflavored Gelatin: We will be using 3 envelopes of plain gelatin. Thanks to the unflavored gelatins, we can adapt any flavors we love. But if you don’t find envelopes, you can just use 2 tablespoons of unflavored gelatin. 

For Sugar Syrup We Need

Water: For making the sugar syrup, we need ¾ cups of water. Don’t add too much – measure them depending on the ingredients. 

Sugar: Use 2 cups of sugar for the syrup. 

Other Ingredients We Need

Flavor Extract: Now, it’s better to mix things up. That’s why we are going to use five different flavors. This way, we can get gumdrops in different colors. We will use peppermint, rum, lemon, cinnamon, and Cherry extracts. 

Granulated Brown Sugar: Keep the granulated sugar for coating

Coarse White Sugar: We also need white sugar for coating. 

Step by Step Instructions

Step 1: Pour cold water into a large bowl to prepare the gelatin mixture. While the gelatin mixture is soaking, we start preparing the sugar syrup. 

Step 2: Take a saucepan and combine 3/4 cup water and 2 cups of sugar. 

Step 3: Bring the sugar syrup to a boil and let it simmer for at least 5 minutes. 

Step 4: Time to add the sugar syrup to our gelatin mixture. Be careful while adding the hot sugar. 

Step 5: Stir to combine until the gelatin is completely dissolved. 

Step 6: We will split the syrup and jello mixture into separate bowls. Now, you can break them into a lot of batches. Mainly, we will use extracts, and you don’t want to mix flavors in one bowl. 

Step 7: On each bowl, we add the food coloring. Just 4 drops or 1/4 teaspoon of food coloring is enough. Add food color bit by bit to get the exact color. 

Step 8: Now, take the 15-count mold to pour the mixture. 

Step 9: Chill the gumdrops overnight in the refrigerator. 

Step 10: Remove the gumdrops from the 15-block mold. 

Step 11: Now, roll the gumdrops in granulated or white sugar.

Pioneer Woman Gumdrop Recipe

Pioneer Woman Gumdrop Recipe

Ever tried Pioneer Woman Gumdrop Recipe at home? It’s super easy to make and adaptable.
Print Pin
Course: Dessert
Cuisine: American
Prep Time: 20 minutes
Cook Time: 4 hours
Total Time: 4 hours 20 minutes
Servings: 2 People
Calories: 80kcal


  • 1/2 Cup Cold Water
  • 3 Envelopes Unflavored Gelatin
  • 3/4 Cup Water
  • 2 Cup Sugar
  • Food Color (Peppermint)
  • Rum
  • Lemon
  • Cinnamon
  • Cherry Extract
  • Granulated Sugar
  • White Sugar


  • Prepare the gelatin mixture
  • Prepare the sugar syrup
  • Add sugar syrup to the gelatin mixture and stir.
  • Split the jello mix in separate bowls
  • Add 4 drops of food coloring on each bowl
  • Pour the mixture into different bowls
  • Chill gumdrops overnight
  • Remove gumdrops from the mold
  • Roll candy with sugar


You pry the gumdrops out of the molds. Well, that’s hard work for sure. But be careful while prying them out.


Nutrition Facts
Pioneer Woman Gumdrop Recipe
Amount per Serving
% Daily Value*
Saturated Fat
Monounsaturated Fat
* Percent Daily Values are based on a 2000 calorie diet.

How to Soften Gummy Candy?

Gummy candies are made of water, sugar, gelatin and food additives. Once the water inside gumdrops evaporates, the candy will get hard. Now, you have to rehydrate them. Just toss the gumdrops in a bowl of warm water. Make sure you don’t use cold water. It’s because gummy candies are soluble to only warm water. The longer you keep the Gumdrops in warm water, the more water it absorbs. 

But keeping it in warm water for 20 minutes is enough to make the candies softer.

Wrapping Up

See? It’s not hard to make Christmas jelly candy. Just follow our simple instructions and you can prepare these candies at home.

You May Like Also:

Pioneer Woman Chuck Fudge Recipe

Recommended Articles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *